Evaluation of gap-filling methods for Landsat 7 ETM+ SLC-off image for LULC classification in a heterogeneous landscape of West Africa

Abstract

The Landsat mission which has existed over five decades has remained at the forefront of providing consistent moderate spatial and temporal resolution optical images of the earth. The failure of the scan line corrector (SLC) on board the Landsat 7 Enhanced Thematic Mapper Plus (ETM+) in May 2003 has permanently resulted in data gaps on each Landsat 7 scene. Due to the obvious negative impacts on the image usability, a number of methods have been developed to fill the no-data areas in the image. This study assessed the performance of four Landsat 7 ETM+ SLC-off gap-filling methods in a highly heterogeneous landscape of West Africa for two different seasons (dry and rainy). The methods considered are: (1) Weighted Linear Regression (WLR) integrated with Laplacian Prior Regularization Method (LPRM), (2) Localised Linear Histogram Matching (LLHM), (3) Neighbourhood Similar Pixel Interpolator (NSPI) and (4) Geostatistical Neighbourhood Similar Pixel Interpolator (GNSPI). All the images used were Landsat 7 ETM+ SLC-off images, temporally close and from the same season for each set of time step. Visual comparison, mean, and standard deviations of the histograms of all bands of only the filled areas were used to assess the results. Additionally, overall accuracy (OA), kappa coefficient (κ), and balanced accuracy (BA) per class were used to evaluate a land use/cover (LULC) classification based on the gap-filled images. Visually, all the four methods were able to completely fill the gaps in the Landsat 7 ETM+ SLC-off image. They all look similar and spatially continuous with no anomalies or artefacts on them. The histograms from each band for only the filled areas for all the four methods also gave similar means and standard deviations in most cases. All the four gap-filling methods provided satisfactory results (OA >96% and κ> 0.937 in all methods for images in the dry season and OA >93% and κ> 0.877 for the image in the rainy season) in the land cover classification considering the complexity of the study area. But the GNSPI was superiority in all cases with the highest OA of 97.1% and κ of 0.947 in the dry season and OA of 94.6% and κ of 0.899 in the rainy season. This implies that the GNSPI is more robust in gap filling of Landsat 7 ETM+ SLC-off images than the other three methods in a heterogeneous landscape of West Africa regardless of the season. This study suggests that gap filling of Landsat 7 ETM+ SLC-off images will help to increase the number of Landsat images needed to build time-series data for a data-scarce region such as West Africa.